Note: in order to not distract from the essay, I linked to each of the images to an article if you are unfamiliar, rather than put them in the essay and break up the flow.
This is more of an introspective blog post on art history + allowing teenager feelings to flower in productive ways in the classroom. This year, my AP Art History students and a wonderful bunch and it has been incredibly cup filling for me. They have so may thoughts and opinions and they aren’t shy to voice them! Additionally, the group has created such a bond, it has allowed my classroom to become a brave space for conversation. My students have gotten mad and dismissive at art (Fountain), they have struggled to understand (The Bay), they have not wanted to talk about some pieces (Object) and they have cried tears in class (Migration of the Negro). All of this is not only ok, it’s fantastic. Good art should make us feel something, even if that something is revulsion.
This year I have been reading a lot about beauty and many people (in the conservative circles I am reading) lament the “death of beauty.” They blame all sorts of historical events for the degradation of beauty both in life and art depicting it. They’re not wrong, but I think they misplace the purpose of art.
They rail about the death of art in the early 20th century “art for arts sake” movement and believe Picasso killed beauty. While I can firmly say modern art is not my personal favorite, I love teaching it because it pushes us. Beauty is not a linear development, frozen in the halls of Renaissance palazzos. Beauty serves a purpose. I can find beauty in the stark paintings of Kazimir Malevich as much as I see it in a Byzantine icon.
Many of the articles I have been engrossed in happen to be Catholic, philosophers and theologians alike, and many focus on art that serves the Catholic theology of a time related to the Counter-Reformation (maybe some of them give a nod to Impressionism as the “last” great art movement of beauty). However, they seem to gloss over the reductionist tendencies and heightened pattern of early medieval art, they also seem to ignore the late gothic painfully emotional pietás and lamentations that highlight “ugliness” to showcase the pain of the death of Jesus. The Röttgen Pietà is not “beautiful” by their modern definitions, but I think we would be remiss to not see formal connections to de Kooning’s Woman I. Even if de Kooning’s goals are diametrically opposed to that of the German medieval sculpture.
This past week I taught Migration of the Negro by Jacob Lawrence, and my students found profound and deep beauty in it. It surprised me because I never describe his art as traditionally beautiful. They taught me so much in their observations on how using shapes, flattening figures, and distorting linear perspective was so beautiful because of the devastatingly tragic story he was telling. As they pointed out, it would incredibly wrong, indeed a betrayal, if Jacob Lawrence used the “beauty” of the Renaissance to make his art.
It’s ok to feel anger, distain, disgust, or want to dismiss modern and post-modern art. Good art should make us feel something, even if that something is revulsion.
JMF
P.S. the cover image is from the contemporary artist Julie Mehretu; Retopistics: A Renegade Evacuation, 2001.
Read more: One Student’s Musings on Abstract Art